10 Shows That Were Wrongfully Canceled

There are plenty of really bad shows that should be canceled, but instead get another season (I'm looking at you, All's Fair...). Meanwhile, how many times do you fall in love with a show only for it to be axed early? Sometimes we don't even get a proper ending and are left to suffer after a major cliffhanger.

Fans will do their best to resurrect their faves, and occasionally it works. Manifest did come back from the dead to give us the closure we so desperately needed.

But more often than not, we're simply left to wonder about what could have been. And that's the case for these 10 shows that were wrongfully canceled. Did your favorite make the list?

I have bad news for fans of this Emmy-nominated period piece starring Kristen Wiig, Carol Burnett, Laura Dern, Allison Janney, Ricky Martin and Leslie Bibb. Just this week, it was revealed that Palm Royale won't be getting a season three, despite it being a fan-favorite. Fortunately, things wrapped up pretty nicely at the end of season two, but with the show earning 11 Emmy nominations for season one (and the season two noms not even out yet), this does come as surprising news.

SJP tried to act like it was always the plan for AJLT to come to an end after three seasons, but fans weren't quite so sure. For many, the season three finale didn't deliver on the years of build-up for some of TV's most iconic characters ever. Personally, not only did I like the series finale, I found it sweet, significant and satisfying. That said, do I think we've seen the last of Carrie, Charlotte and Miranda? I'm inclined to say yes—but I've thought that before only to get a movie, another movie and a belated reboot. 

I was not happy (nor were the show's many devoted fans) when Boots was given the boot after just one season. You guys, this gay military drama was so good. And even more unfortunate? There's no chance for the series to be scooped up by another streaming service. Per Deadline, "Because of Netflix’s strict exclusivity terms, it is virtually impossible for an outside studio to shop a series after it has been canceled by the streamer." *Sigh*

Yellowstone was definitely one of those shows that could have run for years and years. Unfortunately, due to a bit of, ahem, behind-the-scenes drama, things came to an abrupt end after season five. At least fans can rest easy that the Yellowstone universe will live on with prequel shows like 1883 and 1923. (Does that fill the John Dutton-sized hole in our TV-watching hearts? Sadly, no.)

I take this one personally (not as personally as Lisa Kudrow, I'm sure, but still). The Comeback was my favorite show when it came out back in 2005. It was funny, it was smart...it was canceled. Even Kudrow was shocked to find out it was getting the axe. By some miracle, it was given a second season ten years later. And then by some act of god, it was given a third season ten years after that (the third installment comes out this month). Am I happy we get to find out what Valerie Cherish is up to after all these years? Sure. But I can't help but wonder what could have been if The Comeback hadn't been first canceled all those years ago.

One of my favorite shows of 2024 was undoubtedly Kaos, starring Jeff Goldblum, Janet McTeer, Eddie Izzard and Debi Mazar. From start to finish, the performances are incredible. The Greek mythology-inspired plot is also a (pleasant) roller coaster of emotions. In a single weekend, I'd binged the entirety of season one, already hungry for Kaos season two to arrive. But, alas, season two was not meant to be, with Netflix declining to renew the show.

Unless you've been living under a rock, you've heard about the cancelation—and subsequent controversy surrounding the cancelation—of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. It was quite the bold move for CBS to put an end to the long-running late-night talk show, and Colbert stans were anything but happy. Colbert will, no doubt, land another major gig of some kind soon, but late-night TV just won't be the same without him.

It's been a year since we first learned that The Sex Lives of College Girls wouldn't be continuing on after season three. At first, there were rumors that the show was being shopped around to hopefully extend elsewhere. Sadly though, nothing has (thus far) come to fruition. The third season didn't really leave fans with any major cliffhangers, but the girls were only halfway through their sophomore year so there were still plenty of storylines left to explore before college graduation.

In my book, Megan Stalter can do no wrong, and that was particularly the case with her laugh-out-loud Netflix rom-com Too Much. The series starred Stalter as Jessica, a heartbroken thirty-something New Yorker who decided—very impulsively—to move to London after a breakup left her emotionally wrecked. And it came from the genius brain of Girls mastermind Lena Dunham. Reports tried to frame the lack of a season two as being part of the plan: "It was only meant to be a limited series," they cried. But something tells me if the ratings had been higher (why weren't you watching with me, people?!), there would've been a season two.

White Lotus fan-favorite Natasha Rothwell made it known that she was "shocked, heartbroken and frankly, baffled" to learn that her Hulu comedy series How to Die Alone had been canceled after only a single season. Same, Natasha. The show followed a lonely JFK airport employee who had a brush with death on her birthday. And though not enough people watched to earn it a season two, at least that means there are plenty of people who are lucky enough to still get to enjoy season one for the first time.

Did your favorite canceled show make the list? Here are a few others that bit the dust far too soon...

• Life & Beth
• The Mick
• Mid-Century Modern
• Mindhunter
• Santa Clarita Diet
• The OA
• Arrested Development

Want all the latest entertainment news sent right to your inbox? Click here.