I Tasted 8 Dishes at Martha Stewart’s New Restaurant—Here’s Everything Worth Ordering

From oysters to lemon meringue pie

food at martha stewart restaurant

In my time as a food writer, I’ve had Martha Stewart on the brain often. I’ve made her recipes for one-pan pasta and mashed potatoes. I’ve reviewed her line of Goldbelly pastries. I’ve even ventured out (in several seasons) to taste Martha Stewart’s Maman menus of pastries, drinks and sandwiches. Still, I’ve always wondered what it would be like to taste her food—not a recipe, not a pre-packaged item with her name on it, but something she cooked herself. I’ve yet to receive a dinner invitation to her Bedford, New York property, but I did do the next best thing by going to her newly opened restaurant. 

The Bedford, located inside Foxwoods Resort Casino in Connecticut, opened in March 2026. It’s the lifestyle icon’s second eatery, the first having been The Bedford at Paris Las Vegas, which opened in 2022. I made the trek from Philadelphia to Mashantucket to taste some of the most essential dishes on the menu. Below, you’ll find a ranking of eight plates from starters to dessert, complete with original photos. Read on for my honest takes. 

I Tried Martha Stewart’s Popular Banana Bread Recipe (& Loved the Secret Ingredient)


martha stewart green room in restaurant
Taryn Pire

The Vibe

While Martha won’t be the chef actually preparing your food, her influence is undeniable. After all, the resto is modeled after her 1925 farmhouse. We had a table in The Green Room, fittingly painted a serene shade of sage. I spotted the vintage kitchenware on the walls immediately; Stewart collects plates like these to use in her own home.

The room also has a video feed through a “window” that shows real footage from Stewart’s grounds. If you have a keen eye, you’ll catch a glimpse of one of her many peacocks—or Martha herself—patrolling the grass while you eat. The servers’ jackets were spotless and tidy. Their lab coat-like look seemed to allude that the cooks had their art down to a science.

The Food

8. Lobster Linguine

  • What It Is: lobster tail, spicy tomato sauce, mint and rustic tartine over linguine
  • Price: $45

This pasta was like Sunday dinner with a Cape Cod twist. While I appreciated the dish’s unexpected touches, I liked it less than everything else we tried. The thick, long noodles were flawlessly al dente and the lobster was plentiful, meaty and beautifully plated. I had a hard time enjoying the mint in the sauce. Its cool, tingly qualities did seem to amplify the spice, but the amount was excessive and clashed with the tomato for me. The garlic bread had a robust flavor, but the bread was chewy and a bit tough to tear.

7. Halibut

  • What It Is: seared halibut, carrots, celery, onions, potatoes, heirloom tomatoes and basil in corn and clam chowder
  • Price: $52

I’m personally a salmon girl, but switched up my order based on a recommendation. It’s also the only dish I had (besides the crispy Parmesan potatoes) that isn’t served at The Bedford in Las Vegas. The halibut was notably firm and meaty. It was stunningly prepared and offered mild sweetness and meaty, photogenic flakes.

The real highlight for me was the chowder though, which I felt was a really fun, comforting substitute for sauce. The summery-sweet corn shone with every drop, and the clams were delightfully chewy. Overall, the chowder’s texture was luscious but not overwhelmingly heavy.

6. House-Made Bread Basket

  • What It Is: garden vegetable crisps, sour cherry-rosemary focaccia and warm Parker House rolls with Vermont Creamery butter
  • Price: $23

I love when a restaurant takes the time to craft an OTT bread basket. This one was as photogenic as it was creative. The classic Parker House rolls are essentially fluffy yeast clouds with mild sweetness and a croissant-like butteriness on the nose. The butter’s clean, milky flavor reminded me of fior di latte with a salty kick. (FYI, Vermont Creamery is one of Martha Stewart’s favorite butters.) The vegetable crisps, complete with zucchini and onion, were cracker-thin, yet still slightly tender due to the produce. Herbs like thyme imparted a vague pizza energy to the crisps. The focaccia delivered the signature moist, doughy chew you expect, but with juicy pockets of sweet-tart cherries. The herbs provided a savory complement to the fruit.

5. Big Martha’s Pierogi

  • What It Is: potato filling, brown butter
  • Price: $22

Did you know Martha is of Polish descent? Our server told us that the restaurant uses her mom’s pierogi recipe, and I can attest that they’re the real deal. They had a thicker-than-store-bought homestyle dough, which emphasized their rustic flavor. Despite the exterior's thickness, the pierogi were still surprisingly soft. The tender, starchy interior’s simplicity was elevated just right by the silky, nutty, sage-kissed butter without detracting from its frill-free charm.

4. Raw Oysters

  • What It Is: six local oysters with red wine mignonette and cocktail sauce
  • Price: $23

Honestly? These were some of the most delicious oysters I’ve ever had. Our server told us they were locally sourced in Connecticut. They had a delicately briny, flavor and clean minerality. The cocktail sauce was classic, but the punchy, fragrant mignonette was my favorite pairing (besides fresh lemon, of course). It brought a ton of vibrancy to the oysters’ natural freshness.

3. New York Strip

  • What It Is: 14-ounce steak with braised leek, watercress and bordelaise
  • Price: $58

We ordered the steak medium rare, and the kitchen delivered. It was thoroughly juicy with an impressive outer sear. While the steak itself was a home run, I’d recommend keeping the sauce (bordelaise, a French brown sauce usually made with red wine, butter and demi-glace) on the side for dipping and drizzling instead of pouring it atop the entire steak. The onion it came with was really bright and fall-apart tender with a stunningly charred, frilly outer skin. The flawlessly tender-crisp watercress added peppery, slightly bitter contrast.

We paired the steak with two sides: sautéed Spinach with shallots ($15) and crispy Parmesan potatoes ($15). I appreciated the vegetal simplicity of the greens, thankful that they weren’t creamed. They weren’t mushy, but rather retained some bite. The potatoes genuinely tasted like Parm fries in a more elegant package. Due to their shape, they were fluffy and tender inside.

2. Upside-Down Lemon Meringue Pie

  • What It Is: baked meringue, lemon curd and whipped cream
  • Price: $14

I don’t know Martha personally, but this dish felt so her. The old-school dessert was made nearly unrecognizable in terms of appearance, but it didn’t reinvent the wheel either. It was classic and basic, yet exquisitely executed from every angle and undeniably beautiful. I loved the contrast of soft, marshmallow-y meringue alongside crisp, delightfully foam-like hard meringue. The vanilla notes were a delectable match for acidic, silky lemon curd.

1. Crab Cake

  • What It Is: jumbo lump crab, roasted yellow peppers and celeriac slaw
  • Price: $30

Our server told us this was her favorite item on the menu; it turns out that it’s mine, too. This was a quality, no-nonsense crab cake—maximum meat, minimum filler and worth every penny. I liked that the cake was bound largely by the thick, crunchy sear rather than a ton of breading, not to mention that it was perfectly salted. The tartar sauce was made from scratch and sang with notes of dill pickle. Even the slaw was perfect, checking boxes for bitter, sweet and sour, which all played well with the clean, buttery crab.

All in all, Stewart’s newest location of The Bedford is well worth a visit. While there’s gambling to be had at the Foxwoods casino, ordering a stellar dinner here is essentially a sure thing. 


taryn pire 3

Taryn Pire

Food Editor

  • Spearheads PureWow's food vertical
  • Manages PureWow's recipe vertical and newsletter
  • Studied English and writing at Ithaca College